Some partnerships are intended to last for many years, while others merely cover specific projects. Regardless of the nature of a partnership, it is always critical to document the parties’ respective rights, responsibilities and expectations through a comprehensive agreement. When a valid document is not executed, that can trigger costly litigation if a dispute arises. However, a recent case demonstrates that even without a formal, written agreement, a judge or jury might find that a partnership existed.
Two Texas companies, Enterprise Products Partners and Energy Transfer Partners (ETP), worked together on a proposed joint venture known as the “Double E” pipeline. Upon completion, the pipeline would have transported crude oil from Oklahoma to the Gulf Coast. Enterprise and ETP signed letters of intent relating to the venture and collaborated on marketing and financing efforts.
Apparently, the project did not attract enough interest, and Enterprise abandoned the venture, opting instead to work on a similar pipeline development deal with a Canadian company. ETP sued for hundreds of millions of dollars in damages, disgorgements and interest stemming from the scuttled partnership. Enterprise countered that because formal contracts had not been executed and definitive conditions had not been met, no legally enforceable partnership had ever existed.
In Texas State District Court, the jury held that a partnership had been formed despite the lack of a formal agreement, and awarded ETP more than $500 million. Under the state’s Business Organization Code, the existence of a partnership can be assessed based on the totality of circumstances, of which the execution of a partnership document is just one factor. This can be true under Arizona law as well.
Don’t make the mistake of believing that the absence of a written agreement can shield you from a costly partnership dispute. If your day-to-day operations resemble a joint enterprise, that might suffice to establish a legal relationship. Accordingly, you should formalize your arrangements with a commercial partner even if you are not sure about the future of the proposed joint venture. While documents such as letters of intent, term sheets and NDAs should expressly disclaim the creation of a legal partnership if that is what you desire, remember that your actions count as well. Telling customers, regulators or investors that you are “partners” can trigger responsibilities that you never intended.
The Law Offices of Donald W. Hudspeth P.C. in Phoenix advises Arizona clients on various relationships between businesses and provides strong advocacy in partnership disputes. For a consultation, please call 866-696-2033 or contact us online.